Copyright Infringement Cases: 2 Examples

Despite the fact that most people believe that content theft is a growing problem in the worlds of business and entertainment, most cases of copyright infringement are actually resolved through voluntary actions.

When it comes to copyright infringement, the law is not black and white. It’s a complex issue that can get very confusing for consumers. There are many different options when dealing with a copyright infringement claim and it’s important to know what your rights are, especially to learn them from a Copyright Lawyer Houston. Here are several examples of major copyright infringement cases that have been pursued in the federal courts, and the extent of success each party has achieved in a particular case.

Perfect 10, Inc. v. Google, Inc. (2007)

There is a fine line between “copyright infringement” and “fair use.” The Fair Use provision of the Copyright Act (section 107) indicates that a copyrighted work can be legally reproduced, performed, or broadcast by a third party without authorization under certain circumstances, such as for educational or informational purposes.

Perfect 10 is an adult website specializing in “natural,” unaltered pictures of women. The owner aggressively pursued copyright protection of its imagery, having filed more than 20 lawsuits for infringement, out of fear of a loss of revenue. 

One high-profile case involved Perfect 10 alleging Google of copyright infringement for displaying & indexing its subscription-only content on Google image search – as a byproduct of other infringing companies displaying this content.

Google’s image search algorithm automatically indexes and displays pictures from other websites in its search engine results. Google does this with a fair use intent: the images are simply links to the websites that host them. This provides searchers a further means to access & discover websites of interest. Nowadays, Google image search displays a notice that images displayed may be subject to copyright – meaning that if a searcher were to download and use the image themselves, respecting copyrights would then be the searcher’s responsibility.

The verdict of the case was ultimately that Google was not infringing on Perfect 10’s copyright, pointing out similar cases proving that the fair use of copyrighted material for information retrieval is a benefit to the general public. Any infringement would’ve been on the websites indexed by Google, not on Google themselves.

You can save many years and tons of money by consulting a lawyer first to determine whether a third party is infringing on your rights, or simply partaking in fair use. In certain cases, fair use can actually be of benefit to the copyright owner by encouraging & driving sales.

A&M Records, Inc. v. Napster, Inc.


By the start of the 2000’s, the internet was relatively in its infancy, and yet affordable enough for music to be easily streamed, shared & downloaded online at an accessible bitrate. Napster was a peer-to-peer MP3 sharing network that allowed users to upload music for others to hear for free. The efficiency of doing so even resulted in the “leakage” of then-unreleased songs by major recording artists, such as Metallica.

Within less than a year after its 1999 release, Napster exploded as the pre-eminent way for internet users to listen to bootlegged music. Before long, the perceived threat to music sales was large enough that numerous major record companies took legal action against Napster for copyright infringement. By 2002, after the case was closed, Napster had ceased to exist, though this lawsuit certainly did not deter free online music-sharing.

Today, an abundance of music can be viewed & shared on YouTube, largely as a result of licensing agreements between YouTube and record companies – where YouTube pays a portion of ad revenue to the record companies for streaming videos of music they hold copyright to, even when the uploader was not authorized to do so. Whether music on YouTube constitutes infringement or not is debatable, as some argue that it is “fair use” and actually encourages music sales.

If you want to protect your copyrighted material, or are being sued for infringement, we highly recommend consulting with and retaining a Lloyd & Mousilli copyright lawyer.

Options For Florida Taxpayers

The Florida tax relief system is in the midst of something of a renaissance. After all,we were just a little over a decade ago when the George Bush administration decided to open up one of the most unproductive tax havens in the world,the Bahamas. Because of this,we lost an incredible amount of business and jobs in the state and suffered a severe economic backlash as a result. But things are looking much better these days in the Sunshine State,at least when it comes to abatement and penalty abatement. Business owners can now benefit from the IRS by claiming back taxes owed,claiming penalty abatement,and claiming interests paid off.Get a Free Consultation on Tax Relief

The first thing to understand about the new,simplified process for filing a return is that you must file your return with the Florida Department of Revenue by the actual due date of your return. If you do not file this return,then the state will automatically assume that you have already claimed all of the tax credits,rebates,and state income tax payments that you are legally entitled to. As a result,the refund request must be filed with the Florida Department of Revenue within two weeks of the filing of your original return. The tax issues that you face will be completely different when you file your return electronically as opposed to filing by mail.

Get Relief from Taxes Now

Another great option that many filers are taking is to claim penalty abatement and back taxes owed on their Florida corporate income tax returns. What exactly is penalty abatement? Simply put,this is an opportunity for Florida taxpayers to wipe out their Florida corporate income tax liability by claiming an amount equal to the balance of the penalty abatement. This means that if you owe Florida property taxes,but no corporate income tax,you can reclaim the same amount of property tax through claiming a penalty abatement,which is a refund of the difference between the Florida property tax that you actually owe and the amount of excess tax that you can claim for a tax lien reduction or an expatriation exemption.

tax relief service

Reasons Why Getting Out Of Debt Is Possible

If you have credit card debt and are in a financial bind,it is possible to get Alabama Debt Relief Help to help you out. There are many reasons why this is possible,but mainly because of the federal stimulus money that has been provided by the government to help those who are having difficulties with their finances. This money does not have to be repaid and that is the main reason why the government has provided such help. The government is helping those who are having trouble paying their bills. This is all about the stimulus money.

Get Debt Free! Click Here

You can also get help with your great credit card debts if you are having some hard times and are having a tough time making your payments each month. You need to be careful when looking for an Alabama Debt Relief Help service. You do not want to end up with a program that will take advantage of you and leave you with nothing. Make sure that the company that you are choosing to use has good records in the past. They should be able to offer you something that will work well with your situation and help you in your future.

First Choice Credit Management

When choosing a company,make sure that they are able to meet your needs and wants. You need to have all of the information that you need before you choose a company. You can get a good idea of what you need by visiting the websites of different companies and talking with the people who work there. You can talk with them about how long they have been in business,the services that they provide,and what other options are available. You need to know everything about your situation so you can find a solution that works. If you are going to use an online service,make sure that you check their reviews as well.

https://www.alabamadebtreliefhelp.com/debt-consolidation-montgomery-al/